An organization responsible for Amsterdam’s historic Portuguese Synagogue recently apologized to Dr. Yitzhak Y. Melamed, a professor of philosophy at Johns Hopkins University, whom a resident rabbi last week declared persona non grata due to a centuries-old edict against the philosopher Baruch Spinoza.
“We regret that a perfectly normal request to visit the premises of the Portuguese Synagogue … has led to an international uproar,” Michael Minco and Emile Schrijver wrote Dec. 1 to Dr. Melamed, an Israeli-born Pikesville resident who is the Charlotte Bloomberg Professor of Philosophy at Hopkins.
Dr. Melamed sought access to the synagogue to make a documentary about Spinoza, whom the Portuguese Jewish community of Amsterdam excommunicated in 1656 for writings that it deemed heretic. Rabbi Joseph Serfaty last week rejected Dr. Melamed’s request in a letter that the scholar posted on Facebook.
The ban “remains in force and cannot be rescinded. You have devoted your life to the study of Spinoza’s banned works and the development of his ideas,” Rabbi Serfaty wrote. “I therefore deny your request and declare you persona non grata in the Portuguese Synagogue complex.”
But Rabbi Serfaty acted without approval from the board of the Jewish Cultural Quarter, a city-funded institution that runs the Jewish Museum of Amsterdam and the non-religious components of the synagogue, according to Minco and Schrijver, the head of the board of directors of the synagogue and the head of the Jewish Cultural Quarter, respectively.
Rabbi Serfaty’s decision was overturned, they wrote, and Dr. Melamed is welcome to visit the synagogue and its library.
“We do hope that you will decide to pursue your plans to come to Amsterdam to do your work as requested,” Minco and Schrijver wrote in the letter. “We are looking forward to welcoming you.”
Dr. Melamed posted to Facebook on Dec. 2 after previously disclosing that he had received an apology from Minco and Schrijver but that he had been instructed not to publicize it. He also said he had received a letter with “fresh maledictons” from Rabbi Serfaty.
Rabbi Serfaty has apologized in a statement for “the way in which the letter was sent” to Melamed but stands behind its content, according to the Dutch Jewish news site Jonet. Rabbi Serfaty did not reply to repeated requests for comment this week from the Jewish Telegraphic Agency.
Cnaan Liphshiz writes for the JTA global Jewish news source.
A committed philanthropist and community leader, Russel was president of R&H Motors.
The mother of four was a native of Winchester, Virginia, who spent most of her life in Northwest Baltimore.
The remaining 6,000 members of the community are expected to immigrate by 2030.
The Columbia resident worked on the Gemini and Apollo space missions.